
5 Things to Look for in a Great Coach
The coach you LIKE the most isn't always the coach who will help you GROW the most.
5 THINGS TO LOOK FOR IN A GREAT COACH
One of the books I've enjoyed is The Little Book of Talent by Daniel Coyle. It's a short book filled with practical ideas about how people develop skills and what separates effective practice from simply putting in the time.
One section that stood out to me was his advice on choosing a high-quality coach.
After ten years of coaching, working alongside other coaches, and watching my own kids learn from different teachers and mentors, I've come to appreciate just how important this decision is.
Not all coaching is created equal.
And while we often evaluate coaches by their playing experience, personality, win-loss record, or how much athletes enjoy being around them, I think there are better questions we should be asking:
Is this person actually helping athletes become better?

Inspired by Coyle's five suggestions, here are five things I believe athletes and parents should look for those who coach their athletes. 👊
1. Beware of the "Buddy Coach."
In The Little Book of Talent, Daniel Coyle warns against coaches who remind you of courteous waiters.
I think of them as "Buddy Coaches."
You know the type. They're friendly, encouraging, and fun to be around. They want athletes to feel good, practices to run smoothly, and everyone to leave happy.
And while those qualities aren't necessarily bad, they become a problem when a coach cares more about being liked than helping athletes improve.
I've seen coaches who are so concerned with being liked that they begin functioning more like peers or friends than professionals.
They constantly compliment athletes, avoid uncomfortable conversations, and hesitate to hold anyone accountable because they don't want to damage the relationship.
But there's a difference between building a relationship with an athlete and needing an athlete's approval.
Great coaches absolutely should care about their athletes. They should encourage them, celebrate their progress, and create an environment where athletes feel respected and supported.
But they also have to be willing to tell the truth.
If a coach's primary concern is whether you like them, whose development is really being prioritized?
A great coach doesn't need you to like every decision. They need to care enough about your development to make the right one.
2. Seek the "Professional Coach."
In contrast to the Buddy Coach, a great coach might actually make you a little uncomfortable.
Coyle suggests looking for someone who scares you a little.
And I think there's something important in that idea.
Not fear of being embarrassed, humiliated, or mistreated.
I'm talking about the kind of nervousness you experience when you're around someone whose standards are higher than what you're accustomed to.
They watch closely. They notice details. They're honest about what they see, sometimes uncomfortably so.
They don't sugarcoat your performance or tell you what you want to hear.
They tell you what you need to know.
And sometimes, the truth stings.
That's not necessarily a bad thing.
One of the most valuable things an athlete can learn is how to receive correction without taking it personally.
Not every correction needs to be wrapped in a compliment. Not every uncomfortable conversation means someone has been unkind.
Sometimes your coach is simply telling you what needs to change. They're giving you information about your performance—information you can use to get better.
The sooner you develop a little thicker skin, the sooner you can stop focusing on how the feedback made you feel and start using it to get better.
The Buddy Coach wants you to feel good. The Professional Coach wants you to get better.
That doesn't mean great coaches should humiliate or belittle athletes. But it does mean they shouldn't have to tiptoe around the truth.
Great coaches can be demanding without being demeaning.
And athletes who learn to receive honest feedback without becoming defensive have an enormous advantage.
So, parents, if your child comes home and says their coach is intense, intimidating, or even a little scary, don't automatically assume that's a bad thing.
Ask them why.
If it's because their coach has high expectations, pays attention to the details, and isn't afraid to tell them the truth, you can relax.
They may have just encountered a professional.
3. Look for a coach who makes COMPLICATED things SIMPLE.
One of the most valuable skills a coach can develop is the ability to communicate clearly.
Not just knowing what an athlete needs to do, but knowing how to help them do it.
We've all seen it. A coach gives an athlete five or six corrections at once.
Move your feet. Get lower. Watch the ball. Keep your platform out. Don't swing your arms. Finish toward your target.
And then wonders why the athlete doesn't immediately improve.
Sometimes we overwhelm athletes with so much information that they can't actually use any of it.
Great coaches know how to identify what matters most.
They watch. They listen. They make a connection. And then they give the athlete something useful to work with.
Sometimes that's one simple instruction.
One adjustment.
One question.
And then an opportunity to try again.
This is something I continue to work on in my own coaching.
It's easy to talk too much, especially when you care about helping someone improve.
But more information doesn't always mean better coaching.
And sometimes, the best coaching isn't verbal at all. It's changing the environment, adjusting the challenge, or creating a situation where the athlete can discover the solution through practice.
Great coaching isn't measured by how much the coach talks. It's measured by how much the athlete learns.
4. Look for a coach who loves the FUNDAMENTALS.
It's easy to think fundamentals are for beginners.
But the better an athlete becomes, the more important those fundamentals become.
Footwork. Timing. Balance. Body positioning. Ball control.
Great coaches understand that advanced skills are built on strong fundamentals. And no matter how good an athlete gets, there's always room to improve them.
One red flag? A coach who only wants to work with older, more advanced athletes, or who would rather scrimmage and play games than spend time teaching skills.
Great coaches love teaching. They enjoy breaking down skills, finding ways to help athletes improve, and building the foundation that makes higher-level performance possible.
Fundamentals aren't something you graduate from. They're something you continue to master.
The sooner you find a coach who loves teaching them, the better off you'll be.
Watch our 15 ELITE team highlights
5. Look for a coach who is still learning how to coach.
Coyle's final suggestion is that, all things being equal, you should choose the older coach.
His reasoning is simple: coaching, like any other skill, takes time to develop.
I agree, but I'd take it a step further.
Experience matters. But experience alone doesn't make someone a great coach. Neither does being a great athlete.
Some of the most talented volleyball players struggle to explain how they do what they do. When you've performed a skill thousands of times, much of it becomes automatic.
But performing a skill and teaching it are two very different things.
Take hitting, for example.
An athlete hits the ball out of bounds, and the coach immediately says, "Snap your wrist!"
How many times have we heard that?
But was the wrist actually the problem?
Maybe it was their footwork, approach angle, timing, arm swing, or contact point. Maybe it was a combination.
A coach who immediately repeats a familiar correction without identifying the actual problem may simply be repeating something they've heard a thousand times.
Knowing how to perform a skill is not the same as knowing how to teach it.
This is especially important when hiring former college athletes. Playing at a high level provides valuable experience, but it doesn't automatically make someone an effective teacher.
Great coaching requires the ability to recognize problems, understand why they're happening, and know how to help athletes improve.
That takes study, practice, mentorship, and experience.
Some great coaches are young. Others have decades of experience.
What matters isn't just how long they've coached, but how intentionally they've worked to become better at it.
After ten years, I coach differently than I did when I started. And I hope I can say the same thing ten years from now.
Because if we're asking athletes to take responsibility for getting better, we should hold ourselves to that same standard.
Great coaches never stop learning how to coach.

